Two sharp edge sets, one decision
If you're choosing between Oathkeeper and Poisoner's Delight, you're looking at two handmade sharp edge dice sets from Everything Dice. Both include the full polyhedral set—D4, D6, D8, D10, D%, D12, and D20—and both are priced at USD 52.14 (with a catalog comparison price of USD 79.00). The real difference comes down to design and how each set's handmade character shows up at the table.
Design and table presence
Poisoner's Delight leans into a toxic green-black palette with holographic foil. It's a bold, aggressive look that suits characters with a darker or more mischievous edge. Oathkeeper, by contrast, is described as reserved, with opalescent holographic foil and copper & gold foil. It reads as more elegant and understated, though still eye-catching when the light hits it.
Because both sets are handmade, the exact placement of inclusions and foil will vary. The catalog notes that Poisoner's Delight will vary in inclusion placement and gradient ratios, while Oathkeeper varies in color proportions and foil placement. So if you're after a specific look, expect some individuality rather than a perfectly uniform product.
What the catalog confirms
- Poisoner's Delight: Poisoner's Delight is a toxic green-black design with holographic foil and includes one D4, D6, D8, D10, D%, D12, and D20. Confirms the exact color story and full dice set you'll receive, helping you match the set to your character or table aesthetic.
Poisoner's Delight - Oathkeeper: Oathkeeper is a reserved design with opalescent holographic foil and copper & gold foil, and includes one D4, D6, D8, D10, D%, D12, and D20. Shows the more subdued but still striking foil combination, useful if you prefer an elegant look over a bold one.
Oathkeeper
Handmade variation: what to expect
Both sets are handmade by Everything Dice's resin artists and quality-inspected to be visually perfect and suitable for casual play. That means you get a set that's ready to use, but you won't get two identical dice sets. The catalog explicitly states that each set will vary slightly—Poisoner's Delight in inclusion placement and gradient ratios, Oathkeeper in color proportions and foil placement. If you're the kind of player who values a one-of-a-kind set, this is a plus. If you need exact symmetry, you may want to consider a mass-produced alternative.
Shipping and processing differences
There's a small but practical difference in fulfillment. Poisoner's Delight ships within 1–2 days of ordering, while Oathkeeper ships in 1–3 business days. Both have the same shipping windows: 3–5 days to the US, 7–9 days to Canada, 9–14 days to Australia and New Zealand, and 3–6 weeks everywhere else. Oathkeeper's record also notes that international shipping has been delayed lately and can take up to 1–2 months, so if you're ordering from outside the US, factor in extra time.
Oathkeeper vs Poisoner's Delight at a glance
- Design: Poisoner's Delight: toxic green-black with holographic foil. Oathkeeper: reserved with opalescent holographic foil and copper & gold foil.
- Dice included: Both sets include one D4, D6, D8, D10, D%, D12, and D20.
- Price: Both are USD 52.14, with a catalog comparison price of USD 79.00.
- Handmade variation: Poisoner's Delight varies in inclusion placement and gradient ratios. Oathkeeper varies in color proportions and foil placement.
- Processing time: Poisoner's Delight ships in 1–2 days. Oathkeeper ships in 1–3 business days.
Which set should you choose?
Your choice really comes down to the vibe you want at the table. If you're rolling for a poisoner, necromancer, or any character with a bit of menace, Poisoner's Delight's green-black and holographic foil will fit the role. If you prefer something more refined—think paladin, cleric, or a character with a quiet confidence—Oathkeeper's opalescent and copper-gold foil is the more reserved pick.
Both sets are handmade, so you're getting a unique piece either way. And since they're priced identically, you can let your aesthetic preference be the deciding factor. Just keep the shipping differences in mind if you're on a deadline.
